Last updated: 11 November 2026 | By Pratham Shetty
Quick answer: To compare two job offers fairly, ignore the CTC headline and compare what you can actually count on: fixed pay, plus the share of variable pay you realistically expect, plus benefits you would otherwise pay for, minus extra costs such as commute or higher rent. Enter both offers below and the calculator shows the real yearly and monthly difference, and which offer has more guaranteed money.
Job Offer Comparison Calculator
Two offers, side by side, beyond the CTC number.
Offer A
Offer B
A candidate once turned down my offer of ₹10 lakh for another company’s ₹12 lakh. Fair enough. Eight months later he called to ask if the role was still open. His ₹12 lakh had ₹3.6 lakh of variable pay, the team had not hit its targets, and he was spending ₹4,000 a month more on travel. On paper he had gained ₹2 lakh. In his bank account he was behind. I have seen this story repeat often enough that I now ask every candidate with two offers to run this comparison first.
Why CTC Is the Wrong Number to Compare
CTC is a company’s total cost, and every company builds it differently. One may include a large performance bonus. Another adds a joining bonus that comes only once. A third counts insurance premiums and gratuity. Two offers with the same CTC can differ by several thousand rupees a month in what you actually receive.
A fair comparison needs four separate numbers for each offer.
The Four Numbers That Matter
- Guaranteed money. Fixed pay minus the extra costs that job brings. This is what you get even in a bad year.
- Realistic yearly value. Fixed pay, plus the part of variable pay you honestly expect, plus the benefits you value, minus extra costs.
- First-year value. The realistic value plus any one-time joining or retention bonus.
- CTC on paper. Shown only so you can see how far it is from the other three.
The calculator works out all four and tells you when the “winner” changes depending on which number you look at. That warning is the most useful part of the result.
How to Fill Each Box Honestly
Fixed pay
Take the annual fixed component from the offer letter. If the letter mixes employer PF and gratuity into it, keep the treatment the same for both offers so the comparison stays fair.
Variable pay and expected percentage
Enter the full variable amount, then the percentage you expect to receive. Do not leave it at 100% unless you have a reason. Ask the recruiter, “What was the average payout for this team in the last two years?” and, if you can, ask someone who works there. If nobody gives a clear answer, 50% to 70% is a safer assumption than 100%.
Joining and retention bonus
These are one-time payments, so the tool counts them only in the first year. Read the clawback clause. Most joining bonuses must be returned if you leave within 12 months, sometimes 24.
Benefits you value
Only count what you would otherwise pay for yourself. Health cover that includes your parents can be worth a lot. A gym membership you will never use is worth nothing.
Extra monthly costs
Think commute, fuel, parking, higher rent in a new city, or lunch if one office has a free canteen and the other does not. For relocation, spread the one-time moving cost over 12 months.
A Worked Example
| Offer A | Offer B | |
|---|---|---|
| Fixed pay | ₹9,00,000 | ₹8,40,000 |
| Variable pay | ₹1,00,000 (80% expected) | ₹3,60,000 (60% expected) |
| Joining bonus | ₹50,000 | Nil |
| Extra monthly cost | Nil | ₹4,000 |
| CTC on paper | ₹10,00,000 | ₹12,00,000 |
| Guaranteed after costs | ₹9,00,000 | ₹7,92,000 |
| Realistic value per year | ₹9,80,000 | ₹10,08,000 |
| First year incl. bonus | ₹10,30,000 | ₹10,08,000 |
Offer B looks ₹2 lakh better on CTC. On realistic value it is ahead by only ₹28,000 a year, about ₹2,300 a month. On guaranteed money, Offer A is ahead by ₹1,08,000, and in the first year Offer A pays more because of the joining bonus. A person with an EMI to pay would probably pick A. Someone confident about the targets and planning to stay for years might pick B. The point is that the decision is now based on real figures.
What Money Cannot Show
After the numbers, I ask candidates to score these honestly for each offer:
- The manager. You will learn more from a good manager in one year than from a bad one in three.
- The work itself. Will this role add a skill that makes your next job easier to get?
- Stability. How has the company handled layoffs, salary delays and appraisals in the last two years?
- Hours and location. Shift timings, weekend work, days in office and travel time.
- Notice period. A 90-day notice makes your next switch harder than a 30-day one.
- Growth. When is the first appraisal, and is it pro-rated for new joiners?
If the money difference is under 5% to 10%, let these factors decide. A slightly lower offer with a better manager and role often pays back within a couple of years.
Questions to Ask HR Before You Choose
- Can I have the complete salary break-up, with the monthly in-hand figure?
- How is variable pay calculated, how often is it paid and what was last year’s payout?
- Is there a clawback on the joining bonus or relocation support?
- Is PF deducted on full basic or on the ceiling?
- What is the notice period, and is buyout allowed?
- When will my first appraisal be?
Get the answers on email. And please do not use a fake or edited offer to negotiate. Offer letters are verified more often than candidates think, and it ends careers before they start.
To see each offer as monthly take-home, run both through the CTC to in-hand calculator.
Related on Udhar Guide
- How to Negotiate Salary With HR in India
- CTC to In-Hand Salary Calculator
- CTC Breakup Explained: How to Read Your Offer Letter
- Salary Hike Percentage Calculator
Frequently Asked Questions
1. How do I compare two job offers?
Compare fixed pay, expected variable pay, benefits and extra costs separately, then look at non-money factors like role, manager and stability.
2. Should I choose the offer with the higher CTC?
Not automatically. A higher CTC with a large variable part or higher living costs can leave you with less.
3. What percentage of variable pay should I assume?
Use the team’s actual past payout if you can find it. If you cannot, 50% to 70% is a cautious assumption.
4. Is a joining bonus better than a higher fixed salary?
Usually not. A joining bonus comes once and often has a clawback. Higher fixed pay repeats every year and raises the base for future hikes.
5. How do I compare offers in two different cities?
Add the difference in rent, commute and daily expenses as an extra monthly cost for the costlier city.
6. Does the calculator include tax?
No. It compares pre-tax values. If the two offers are far apart, tax can change the gap slightly.
7. What does “guaranteed after costs” mean?
Your fixed pay minus the extra yearly costs of that job. It ignores variable pay and one-time bonuses.
8. Should I count ESOPs?
Only if they can realistically be sold. For unlisted companies, treat them as a possible bonus and not as salary.
9. How do I value health insurance?
Use the premium you would pay to buy similar cover yourself, especially if it includes your parents.
10. The difference is very small. What now?
Decide on role, manager, learning and stability. Money will not be the deciding factor.
11. Can I compare my current job with a new offer?
Yes. Enter your current package as Offer A and the new one as Offer B.
12. Is it fine to share one offer with another company to negotiate?
You can say that you hold another offer and state the figure truthfully. Never share an edited or fake letter.
13. Does this tool save the offers I enter?
No. Everything stays in your browser.
Decide With All Four Numbers
An offer letter is written to look good at the top line. Your job is to read the lines under it. Enter both offers, see which one wins on guaranteed money and which on realistic value, then weigh the role and the people. Whichever you choose, you will know exactly what you are choosing.